Elon Musk has once again spotlighted a pressing issue: the alarming decline in global fertility rates. This week, he warned about a potential demographic collapse that could lead to the extinction of entire populations. His remarks on social media platform X resonate deeply, as he stated, “if current trends continue, Whites will go from being a small minority of world population today to virtually extinct.”
This is not just hyperbole; it follows numerous observations from various analysts about declining birth rates in developed nations. Musk has labeled population decline as “the most serious problem facing civilization.” Data corroborates this assertion, pointing to significant drops in total fertility rates (TFRs) across many Western nations. The TFR must reach at least 2.1 children per woman to sustain a stable population without relying heavily on immigration. Yet, countries like South Korea, Italy, and Spain are experiencing TFRs well below this threshold.
In South Korea, the 2023 fertility rate is a staggering 0.72. Italy sits at 1.24, while Spain and Germany fare little better with rates of 1.19 and 1.46, respectively. The United States has also seen a decline, with its fertility rate dropping to 1.67 from above 2.0 just two decades ago. These unsettling figures, analyzed by experts like Marko Jukic at Bismarck Analysis, indicate a dire outlook for population stability if current trends persist. Jukic has bluntly stated, “A fertility rate below 1.6 means 50% fewer new people after three generations… Mass extinction numbers.”
Musk’s own family situation—he has 12 children—plays into his insistence on the need for action. He argues that immigration cannot remedy the deep-seated issues arising from falling birth rates: “It simply isn’t physically possible to offset billions in population collapse,” he noted. Further, he emphasizes the importance of preserving distinct cultures, underscoring a broader cultural dilemma entwined with declining populations.
The implications extend beyond individual nations. A 2020 study from the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) estimates that by 2100, the global fertility rate could plummet to 1.66, marking a significant departure from the replacement level. This projection signals that over 90 countries will likely see their populations shrink, even when immigration is taken into account. Professor Stein Emil Vollset of IHME highlights the unprecedented nature of these changes. He acknowledges that while increasing access to contraception, education, and economic opportunities for women has benefits, it will also lead to a societal aging that will reshape economies and political priorities.
With Japan’s fertility rate lingering at 1.26 and its working-age populace shrinking by millions, it serves as a stark warning. Demographer Hiroshi Yoshida paints an alarming picture of Japan’s future, suggesting that if current trends hold, the country could have just one child under 14 years old by 2720. Such scenarios, driven by mathematics rather than fantasies, highlight the urgency of addressing this demographic challenge.
Meanwhile, nations like South Korea and Singapore continue to grapple with dangerously low fertility rates. Despite efforts such as financial incentives and subsidized dating services in Singapore, the downward trends remain unchanged. Critics have emerged, asserting that Musk’s language might oversimplify the complexities surrounding these demographic transitions. Organizations like Population Matters express concern that his rhetoric could prompt misguided policies that infringe on reproductive autonomy.
In the United States, demographers are observing a change in family behavior rather than a dramatic collapse. Kenneth Johnson at the University of New Hampshire notes, “It’s not a collapse of the number of births. But we’re seeing a persistent downward trend.” The birthrate in the U.S. has fallen by nearly 20% since its peak in 2007, influenced by several factors, including the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Responses to this demographic crisis have prompted some governments to implement family formation policies. Hungary has introduced lifetime income tax exemptions for women with multiple children, while France provides extensive childcare options. However, such initiatives yield mixed results, as fertility appears bound to cultural, urbanization, and educational trends, not solely economic incentives.
Despite the caution urged by experts regarding Musk’s alarmist tone, the underlying decline in fertility is an undeniable reality. Musk’s assertion that “Many countries are disappearing” echoes a growing awareness of the shifting demographic landscape. His worried depiction regarding the status of Whites in the global population further illustrates a significant long-term trend.
According to Pew Research and United Nations data, Europe’s share of the global populace has fallen from 21% in 1950 to about 10% in 2020. Projections indicate that this number may drop below 7% by 2100, reflective not of active displacement but rather of disparities in fertility rates. Sub-Saharan Africa, in contrast, continues to demonstrate high birth rates, complicating comparisons with the declining figures in Europe and North America.
Musk’s charged framing of these demographic shifts will surely attract criticism, but the reality is that decreasing populations of working-age adults in developed nations are a challenge that must be confronted. The consequences are tangible: fewer workers, an aging retiree population, rising dependency ratios, and threats to cultural continuity.
Even without a cataclysmic forecast, the data points to significant changes on the horizon. As Musk has sternly warned, “If we don’t address this now, civilization will crumble.” Most experts avoid such apocalyptic rhetoric, but they overwhelmingly recognize the urgency of addressing these trends before they exacerbate societal challenges.
"*" indicates required fields
