Comparing the Fall of Rome to Modern-Day Somalia
The recent tweet—”Rome, 320: Somalia, 2025″—evokes a vivid image of two historical moments marked by crumbling governance. It highlights the gradual disintegration observable in Somalia today, characterized by conflict, terrorism, and environmental disaster. Each crisis interacts with the others, compounding the nation’s troubles as the situation spirals deeper into chaos with no apparent resolution.
Despite international support, Somalia’s federal government is outmatched by ongoing violence from Al-Shabaab. Reports indicate significant territorial gains by the militant group in 2025, thwarting government military actions. While the Somali National Armed Forces have had some success in killing senior militants, Al-Shabaab maintains control over critical road networks and rural districts. This suggests a discrepancy between operations on paper and the reality experienced by Somalis on the ground.
Political infighting complicates matters further. The National Consultative Council’s push for direct elections backfired, causing deeper schisms among regional states. Jubaland’s decision to proceed with indirect elections in defiance of federal plans led to armed conflict, and Puntland’s refusal to cooperate only exacerbated existing tensions. As a result, the government’s capacity to govern has weakened, and elections meant to restore stability have been postponed.
This paralysis reverberates through all levels of governance, halting crucial legislative progress aimed at protecting citizens and organizing electoral processes. Meanwhile, opposition figures convening in Nairobi to challenge the government’s plans signal a growing ripple of dissatisfaction with President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s leadership.
The humanitarian consequences of this dysfunction are staggering. With over 7.5 million Somalis enduring severe drought, entire communities face abandonment as water sources dry up. Anab Osman Abdulle’s words echo the despair felt by many: “There is nothing left. Not water. Not food. Only hunger.” Children are particularly affected; projections indicate that 1.85 million will suffer from acute malnutrition, exacerbated by the diminishing operational capacity of emergency feeding centers due to funding shortfalls.
Human rights abuses compound the misery, with Al-Shabaab employing forced recruitment tactics, including the exploitation of children, to solidify its power. At the same time, government forces have committed offenses that contravene international law, undermining any moral authority they might cling to. The failure of law enforcement only heightens the vulnerability of displaced communities; indictments for human trafficking have dropped sharply, revealing a breakdown in the capacity to protect the most at-risk individuals.
The chaotic environment fosters a robust network for terrorist financing and arms trafficking, raising alarms within the international community. As the United Nations Security Council contemplates the continuation of sanctions against Al-Shabaab, dwindling resolve from allies indicates a troubling trend of donor fatigue. This fatigue is visible in the African Union’s transitioning peacekeeping mission, which has faced logistical cuts and delays in troop readiness and morale.
Regionally, escalating tensions do not help Somalia’s plight. Ethiopia’s agreement to recognize Somaliland’s independence has sparked concerns for Somali sovereignty. The deployment of troops by Egypt and Ethiopia underscores the potential for regional conflict, further complicating an already dire situation.
The ongoing fragmentation of institutions in Somalia paints a stark picture. The nation retains its governmental structure, but functionally, it is becoming increasingly ungovernable. The structures may exist, but they do little to mask a government losing its grip on control, revealing a hollow core instead of a robust state. This deterioration parallels the lessons learned from Rome: neglect towards fragile governments can lead to slow collapse, but the repercussions extend far beyond national borders.
As the world watches, the implications of Somalia’s decline remain vital. Not just a national issue, the challenges faced in Somalia can quickly reverberate across East Africa and beyond, posing risks of conflict, mass displacement, and broader security threats. The analogy with Rome serves as a reminder: monumental failures may unfold over years, but the resulting chaos can converge rapidly. Each small moment of failure can lead to an inevitable collapse, echoing through time from ancient civilization to the present day.
"*" indicates required fields
