Former MSNBC host Joy Reid has recently found herself in a new controversy after sharing a viral Instagram video suggesting that “Jingle Bells” was written by Confederate soldier James Lord Pierpont to mock Black individuals through the lens of blackface minstrel shows. The claims in the video hinge on Pierpont’s historical context and alleged slurs found in his other works. Reid, in her post, expressed disbelief with the caption, “Lord have mercy,” and stated, “American history is a horror show.”
This narrative begins with Kyna Hamill’s 2017 research, which Reid cites. Hamill later clarified that her paper focused more on the historical context of minstrel performances rather than emphasizing intent or present-day racism. While her study has been misconstrued, it hasn’t stopped Reid from amplifying the controversial claims regarding the song’s heritage. The original video asserts, “This is where a racist Confederate soldier wrote ‘Jingle Bells’ to make fun of Black people,” which fueled criticism directed at Reid.
Critics, especially from the conservative side, quickly rose to mock Reid’s assertions. Social media lit up as users pointed out the absurdity of dismantling a beloved Christmas song over such claims. In a pointed response, conservative influencer Mario Newful detailed Reid’s Instagram post, noting that her claims could lead to tangible consequences. He highlighted an instance where Council Rock Primary School in New York banned “Jingle Bells” from their holiday concert due to this narrative. This real-world impact underscores how discussions like these can undermine traditional elements of American culture.
Reid’s track record of making racially charged statements only exacerbates the situation. She has been involved in other controversies, including bizarre claims about former President Trump seeking “reparations for white people.” Such comments have further entangled her reputation as a divisive figure. Critics say her approach appears more focused on grievance than fact, leading to ridicule. One social media user commented, “Nothing is safe from the progressive grievance machine. Not Thanksgiving. Not the Fourth of July. And certainly not Christmas songs about sleigh rides.”
Many comments under Newful’s post express both anger and disbelief at Reid’s approach. One accused her of cultural appropriation, stating, “Joy Reid needs to stop appropriating white culture by dyeing her hair blonde.” This reflects a broader frustration with perceptions of cultural and racial identity being manipulated for attention. Another user suggested that Reid’s rhetoric feeds off divisiveness: “Well, if she wasn’t race-baiting or spreading hate, she’d have nothing to say. Grifter be grifting always.”
As the discussions surrounding music and cultural interpretations continue, Reid’s latest controversy raises questions about how history is viewed and presented today. Critics argue that the reimagining of traditional songs and well-established narratives could lead to a cycle of grievance that detracts from their original meaning. While Reid may aim to shed light on historical injustices, the backlash against her shows a growing sentiment: Christmas songs and traditions should remain untouched by modern interpretations that frame them negatively.
In conclusion, Reid’s commentary on “Jingle Bells” showcases the complexities of how historical context can intersect with current cultural discussions. It reveals a tension in America’s ongoing dialogues about race and history. Whether it serves a purpose or simply stirs up contention remains to be seen, but one thing is clear—the backlash suggests a growing desire to preserve cherished traditions without the lens of modern grievance attached.
"*" indicates required fields
