House Speaker Mike Johnson and Republican lawmakers have raised serious concerns about fraud within the Affordable Care Act (ACA), following troubling findings from a government watchdog. Evidence suggests that tens of thousands of taxpayers may be funding a flawed system rife with abuse.
These alarming revelations surfaced during a congressional hearing in Washington, D.C., just weeks before crucial ACA premium tax credits are set to lapse. Central to the dialogue were insights from the Government Accountability Office (GAO) paired with expert testimony highlighting multiple instances of substantial subsidies being paid under questionable circumstances.
Speaker Johnson did not mince words. “This is the system Democrats want to extend without any reform. We can’t have it,” he asserted, condemning the ACA’s subsidized exchanges. In a widely circulated tweet, Johnson pinpointed key indicators of fraud, including the use of duplicate Social Security numbers and payments to insurance providers for individuals who have passed away. “Including $94 million in subsidies paid to those who died, duplicate social security numbers, and nearly two dozen fake enrollments,” Johnson remarked, illustrating the depth of the issue.
The findings resonate with a growing sentiment among Republican lawmakers that the ACA has been mismanaged, benefiting large insurance companies while leaving taxpayers to bear the financial burden. The GAO reported nearly $94 million in premium subsidies incorrectly allocated to insurance providers for deceased individuals, raising critical questions about data verification processes within the system.
Brian Blase, president of the Paragon Health Institute and a former health policy advisor in the Trump administration, further elaborated on the systemic failures plaguing the ACA. “My testimony today will focus on one profound and expanded failure—massive fraud and abuse in the exchanges,” he stated. Blase pointed out that subsidies are being awarded to “ghost enrollees” and that improper payments are reaching insurers despite many enrollees being ineligible or even deceased.
The fraudulent activity extends beyond payments made to the dead. The GAO also uncovered instances of duplicate Social Security numbers and false enrollment information infiltrating the ACA system. Testimony revealed that numerous applications tested for security flaws were fraudulent yet still generated eligibility for subsidies.
Rep. Scott Fitzgerald highlighted the Democratic party’s role in this debacle. “The reality is the Democrats created a boondoggle that has funneled billions of taxpayer dollars directly from the U.S. Treasury to large health insurance companies,” Fitzgerald said. He emphasized that funds are being released without adequate safeguards or accountability, underscoring a lack of oversight in the allocations.
Democrats have pushed back against these claims. Rep. Jamie Raskin argued that the discussion around fraud distracts from efforts to expand healthcare access. “So we talk about healthcare for Americans and they change the subject to talk about fraud. That’s an old trick,” he remarked, framing the Republican arguments as a diversion.
Despite the pushback, statistics indicate valid reasons for alarm. Federal healthcare programs have previously faced scrutiny for improper payments. A 2023 audit by the Department of Health and Human Services revealed that over 450,000 capitation payments—totaling about $318 million—were made inappropriately for deceased individuals between 2009 and 2019. The scale of taxpayer funds funneled with no living recipients is striking.
According to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), the rate of improper payments stands at approximately 5.09%, potentially translating to $31 billion for 2024. Yet, independent organizations believe the figure could soar to $543 billion over a decade, a portion of which involves outdated or mismanaged enrollment data akin to the issues identified within the ACA.
As Senate negotiations continue regarding the renewal of ACA premium tax credits due to expire soon, differing perspectives mark the discussions. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer has branded upcoming votes as crucial for reducing healthcare costs. “Democrats are fighting for lower healthcare costs for the American people. Republicans are fighting with each other,” Schumer asserted.
However, Republicans counter that extending a program identified as poorly managed is irresponsible without substantial reform. “This is not about denying healthcare,” said Sen. Tommy Tuberville. “This is about accountability.” By suggesting a need for bipartisan discussions, Tuberville highlighted the importance of compromise toward a solution that could garner the necessary support.
Nevertheless, public confidence in the ACA is faltering. Numerous instances of flawed enrollments, coupled with a lack of oversight on taxpayer funds, have prompted critics to question why more hasn’t been done to rectify these issues.
Speaker Johnson and other Republican leaders are advocating for a complete overhaul of the ACA framework. Many GOP members are endorsing solutions focused on Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) and deregulated insurance options, reflective of the healthcare plan promoted during the Trump administration. This proposal seeks to prioritize individual choice, price transparency, and reduced government intervention in healthcare.
“Give money to the people, not to bloated systems that don’t know who’s alive and who’s dead,” Johnson asserted in a follow-up remark that encapsulated the urgency of a systemic change.
As both proponents and opponents of the ACA rally for either an extension or a comprehensive rewrite, the situation remains fraught with suspicion and contention. The path forward for subsidized healthcare is precarious, entangled with ongoing debates over fraud, mismanagement, and the divided political landscape. With looming deadlines for premium credits, millions of Americans may soon find themselves facing significant changes to their healthcare coverage—regardless of any reforms or lack thereof.
"*" indicates required fields
