Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch’s call for New York City’s mayor-elect to denounce the phrase “globalize the intifada” reflects growing concerns within the Jewish community. Following a tragic attack on Jews during a Hanukkah celebration in Australia, Hirsch’s plea emphasizes the pressing need for clarity from political leaders regarding language that can incite violence.
In an interview with Fox News Digital, Hirsch articulated the urgency of the moment. “American Jews are on edge,” he noted, responding to the recent violence that claimed the lives of 15 individuals in Sydney. His sentiment highlights a broader anxiety prevalent within many communities, especially in light of rising antisemitism around the globe.
The phrase in question, according to Hirsch, is not just rhetorical. He stated, “‘globalize the intifada’ means Bondi Beach,” linking it directly to the violent attack. Hirsch implored Mamdani and all responsible leaders to recognize this terminology as a “call to mass genocide.” His assertion critiques Mamdani’s previous hesitance to condemn such language, defining it as a fundamental failure of moral responsibility.
Hirsch made it clear that recognizing Palestinian statehood does not equate to endorsing violent rhetoric. “That is different from saying, ‘I believe that the Palestinians deserve a state, and this state should live side-by-side in peace with Israel,'” he said. Here, Hirsch calls for nuanced dialogue, drawing a line between legitimate political discourse and extremist views that threaten peace.
Mamdani’s track record with pro-Palestinian activism complicates his relationship with the Jewish community. As a founding member of the Students for Justice in Palestine chapter during his college years, Mamdani has openly supported Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) against Israel. Hirsch noted, “He has been opposed to the existence of Israel as a Jewish state from childhood,” framing the mayor-elect’s activism as a source of tension among Jewish New Yorkers.
Hirsch warned that rhetoric feeds actions and that anti-Zionist discourse can foster a hostile environment for Jews. “Even the rhetoric of anti-Zionism… generates hostility to Jews and to the Jewish community,” he cautioned, underscoring the pervasive fallout of hateful ideologies. This view posits that words contribute to a culture of violence that transcends political affiliations, impacting the social fabric of New York as a whole.
The rabbi’s recent comments come after significant protests where demonstrators called for an “intifada” and the eradication of Zionists. Such actions further illustrate the urgency for inclusive dialogue and understanding. “If hostility to Jews grows,” Hirsch warned, “then the city itself will become more violent, a nastier place, a less tolerant place.” This foresight urges all New Yorkers to recognize the implications of divisive rhetoric and its potential ramifications for community safety.
Later in the interview, Hirsch expressed a cautious appreciation for Mamdani’s willingness to engage with Jewish leaders, acknowledging the mayor-elect’s outreach efforts. Yet, he reminded Mamdani that the choice to foster unity rests with him. “I just hope for the sake… of the New York City that we all love, that mayor-elect Mamdani will speak judiciously,” he said firmly, urging him to tread carefully in his approach to Israel-related policies.
Mamdani’s condemnation of the Sydney attack signals a shift towards a security posture involving support for Jewish residents. His statement, which includes a commitment to keeping Jewish New Yorkers safe, suggests an awareness of the community’s concerns. But words must be accompanied by responsible actions to ensure genuine safety and solidarity.
Hirsch’s comments resonate beyond local communities; they speak to a national discussion on the responsibilities of leaders and the impact of their language. In a city that is home to the world’s largest Jewish diaspora outside Israel, the choices made by its leadership could determine the safety and cohesion of a diverse populace.
As the political landscape evolves, the discourse surrounding Israeli-Palestinian relations remains charged and complex. Hirsch’s insights offer a crucial reminder that while advocating for peace, leaders must be vigilant against rhetoric that promotes division and violence. In this atmosphere fraught with tension, the onus is on all leaders to ensure their words foster a climate of safety, tolerance, and understanding.
"*" indicates required fields
