YouTuber Logan Paul recently stirred conversation—and some skepticism—when he urged younger generations to explore alternative investments like trading cards and luxury handbags instead of traditional stocks or bonds. His advice, meant to resonate with a younger audience, has sparked widespread attention. In his words, “If you’re young, there are ways to spend and invest your money in ways that might mean more to you than a traditional conservative investment like the stock market.” Paired with a widespread reaction that included a simple yet pointed “Yikes” tweet, his remarks highlight an ongoing shift in how younger Americans view personal finance.
This shift creates a stark generational divide. Millennials and Gen Z are increasingly steering away from conventional investment strategies. Instead, they gravitate toward tangible assets they deem “fun” or culturally significant. Social media platforms like TikTok and Instagram act as breeding grounds for these new ideas, often coming without necessary context or caution. A 2023 Bank of America survey reveals that younger investors now allocate only 47% of their portfolios to traditional stocks and bonds, a sharp contrast to the 74% held by those aged 44 and above. This shift indicates a broader change in attitudes toward investment, pushing toward items like collectibles and cryptocurrencies.
Katy Knox, president of Bank of America Private Bank, emphasized this generational difference, noting that “the portfolio choices of younger people do suggest a perspective shift between the generations.” This is not just a trend fueled by celebrities; it’s reflective of a deeper cultural transformation. On TikTok’s “FinTok,” influencers promote the merits of investing in luxury handbags, particularly Hermès Birkins, often claiming these assets appreciate more effectively than traditional investments. Their posts might showcase impressive statistics, but they lack critical explanation, leaving room for misinterpretation.
Influencer Madé Lapuerta put a positive spin on this philosophy, stating, “Caring about fashion and luxury is not a stupid thing. It’s a very smart thing.” Some data supports this viewpoint; according to Sotheby’s and resale platforms, certain Birkin models have appreciated by as much as 52% year-over-year. Elizabeth Layne, Rebag’s CMO, highlighted how luxury bags are notably stable assets, often less correlated to stock market fluctuations. For many young investors, items like a Birkin or rare trading cards bring a tangible sense of meaning over the abstract nature of stocks.
However, financial experts warn that the perceived benefits of these investments may not hold in practice. Transaction fees, storage conditions, and resale variability often complicate the real-world value of such collectibles. Advisor Allyson Kiel cautioned against treating social media as gospel: “While social media can be an amazing tool, don’t let it be your bible.”
Critics point out that the allure of alternative investments may lead inexperienced investors to take on unnecessary risks without fully understanding their potential downsides. High-end items like autographed memorabilia require specialized expertise for accurate valuation, and trends can change swiftly. What was once in demand can quickly lose its appeal.
The concern deepens with the rising popularity of Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services. These schemes, especially favored by Gen Z, come with high interest rates and the risk of escalating debt. The 2023 CFPB report indicated that BNPL users often carry high-interest credit card debt and have lower savings. Noah Kerner, CEO of Acorns, urged a more cautious approach, reminding young investors that “the only way to get rich is to get rich slow.” This echoes a more traditional investment philosophy, one rooted in patience and diversification.
Despite these warnings, skepticism among young people persists. Only 14% of wealthy Gen Z and millennials believe stocks represent the best avenue for wealth growth, while 72% think conventional options are unlikely to yield above-average returns in the current economy. The desire to diversify with assets once viewed as hobbies underscores a significant cultural shift in perceptions of success.
This generational skepticism can be attributed to economic volatility, inflation, and a growing distrust of financial institutions. As digital culture evolves, success is increasingly measured by high-profile acquisitions rather than long-term financial stability. Paul’s provocative suggestion to invest in “a piece of a dinosaur” may sound absurd, yet it aligns with a changing cultural narrative that values unique and tangible investments.
To bridge the gap, financial educators stress the need for deeper understanding among younger investors. As social media continues to flood the market with investment advice that often lacks depth, the fundamentals of asset valuation and liquidity become all the more essential. There’s an urgent call for education to evolve alongside these new investment trends, ensuring that risks are adequately disclosed and understood.
This widening gap in investment philosophy suggests that boomers might dismiss what younger investors see as opportunities. What appears to more seasoned adults as collectible junk is increasingly viewed by the young as a pathway to financial success. Only time will reveal the outcomes of this divergent approach to investing, yet one fact stands out: the newest generation of American investors is stepping away from traditional Wall Street guidance.
"*" indicates required fields
