During a recent CNN panel, Scott Jennings directly challenged a liberal guest’s assertion that inflation under President Biden was “naturally occurring.” His sharp quip, “Wait…did it grow on trees?!” quickly went viral, highlighting a significant divide in the understanding of inflation’s root causes.
In recent years, many American families have grappled with rising prices. While some voices in Washington point to global supply chain issues and geopolitical events like Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, economic data indicates that federal policies, particularly extensive pandemic-related spending, played a crucial role. Jennings’s commentary struck at the heart of this debate—was inflation genuinely out of anyone’s control, or was it the result of deliberate choices made in Washington?
The Biden administration’s supporters emphasize international factors. Yet, economic experts draw attention to the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA), an enormous $1.9 trillion relief bill passed in March 2021. Despite a low inflation rate of around 1.7% at the time of its enactment, the flood of federal funds into the economy soon led to soaring prices. By mid-2022, inflation had surged to nearly 9%, a stark reality that hit household budgets hard.
Economist Douglas Holtz-Eakin noted that the monetary stimulus was “significantly larger than the gap it was trying to fill.” He pointed out that this sudden influx of cash buoyed demand when supply chains were already strained. Even within economic circles, the ARPA faced scrutiny, with former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers warning that such an expansive stimulus risked triggering runaway inflation.
While some may argue that global supply chain disruptions outweigh the impacts of domestic policy, even those perspectives concede that ARPA contributed to the inflation crisis. The San Francisco Federal Reserve estimated that fiscal stimulus added about 3 percentage points to the inflation rate by late 2021. This seemingly small increase carries substantial consequences for working families.
From January 2021 to mid-2024, consumer prices soared by approximately 19.4%, while average earnings rose only 17.7%. Although this might suggest a near match, the purchasing power of wages decreased significantly when it comes to essentials like food and fuel. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported a staggering 25% increase in food prices alone since early 2021. Gas prices amplified the strain, reaching a peak of over $5 per gallon before settling around $3.50 in mid-2024. These costs have hit working households particularly hard, where broader economic trends often take a heavy toll on tight budgets.
In a poignant remark during a previous CNN segment, Jennings stated, “Even if you tell me my wages are up 18%, it doesn’t matter if my groceries and rent went up 25%.” This encapsulates the sentiment of many: regardless of wage growth percentages, the reality of increased living costs translates to genuine hardship. It’s a clear message that the struggles faced are not merely a consequence of natural economic fluctuations.
The conversation surrounding inflation has transformed into a vital campaign issue for the upcoming 2024 elections. Former President Trump took to rallying in Wisconsin, claiming the Biden administration’s actions resulted in “the worst inflation in American history.” Such statements illustrate a stark reality—Americans are acutely aware of rising costs, and political narratives continue to evolve to address these issues.
The Federal Reserve’s response, raising interest rates to combat inflation, has created another layer to this complex issue. Higher rates have further inflated mortgage costs, making homeownership increasingly out of reach for first-time buyers. This cycle of economic repercussions has left its mark on families, reshaping spending habits and eroding savings—all while the national debt rises dramatically.
As inflation settles around 3.2% as of mid-2024, the aftermath of earlier decisions is becoming clearer. While families may experience a slight easing in the cost-of-living pressures, the long-standing impact of policies that some dismiss as “natural” will linger. Jennings’s humorous but pointed remark, “Did it grow on trees?” cuts through the rhetoric, resonating with many who feel the weight of rising prices is directly tied to decision-making in Washington.
Ultimately, this debate highlights a deeper frustration: Americans were assured that inflation was transient and then that external circumstances were to blame. Yet, as families sift through their receipts, they recognize that the narrative isn’t as simple as it’s made out to be. The consequences of inflation, beyond mere numbers, translate into real pain and hardship, firmly rooted in choices made by policymakers.
"*" indicates required fields
