DHS Launches Audit of Somali Naturalizations Amid Concerns Over Fraud and National Allegiance
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is taking a significant step by initiating a wide-ranging audit of Somali-born individuals who have gained U.S. citizenship. This investigation will examine the integrity of their naturalization processes and is fueled by allegations of fraud. Reporting by Bill Melugin indicates that the priority will be on investigating potential marriage fraud, especially claims involving Democratic Rep. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota.
This action follows a troubling pattern of fraud within Minnesota’s Somali-American community, which is the largest in the United States. Recent investigations revealed that over $1 billion in federal funds, particularly from welfare programs established during the COVID-19 pandemic, were embezzled. Criminal operations falsely billed the government for feeding nonexistent children, robbing taxpayers through a network of nonprofits like Feeding Our Future. U.S. prosecutors have already secured 59 convictions, signaling the scale of wrongdoing.
U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent stressed the unsettled nature of this financial scandal: “A lot of money has been transferred from the individuals who committed this fraud… We are tracking that both to the Middle East and to Somalia.” These comments underscore the seriousness of the situation as the audit shifts from prosecution to verifying the legitimacy of naturalized citizens and the circumstances under which they obtained their status.
The scrutiny of marriage fraud is particularly notable given the backdrop of allegations surrounding Rep. Omar. She has denied any wrongdoing, and no charges against her have been formally filed. However, comments made by a visiting Somali prime minister have stoked concerns about her loyalties. He suggested that Omar’s priorities lie more with the Somali people and their interests rather than those of American citizens, a remark that reportedly drew her applause.
Certain observers, like Michael Rubin from the American Enterprise Institute, have pointed out the deep ties between Omar’s political stance and her Somali heritage. He remarked, “Ilhan Omar left Somalia, but Somalia never left her… Clan dynamics shape Somali politics.” Such statements pose unsettling questions about the alignment of her political decisions with U.S. interests.
The audit arrives alongside rising diplomatic tensions linked to Somalia’s political landscape, particularly following Israel’s recognition of Somaliland. Omar’s opposition to this recognition has stirred further debate about her position on critical U.S. foreign policy matters in the region.
In addition, the Department of Treasury is investigating whether the misappropriated welfare funds may have aided terrorist organizations like Al-Shabaab. While direct connections between fraud and terrorism remain unproven, Bessent’s comments highlight the depth of the investigation: “We are tracking the flows, and we’re not going to stop until we know where every dollar went.”
Rep. Omar has publicly rejected claims of her involvement in fraudulent activity, arguing that if evidence existed, intelligence agencies would have discovered it by now. “If there was a linkage in the money that they have stolen going to terrorism, then that is a failure of the FBI and our court system in not figuring that out,” she stated. Her defense speaks to broader themes of racial dynamics in the investigation, which she characterizes as an attack on her community. Boldly, she claims, “These are Americans that [Trump] is calling garbage,” warning of the dangers of dehumanizing rhetoric.
Yet, the mood on Capitol Hill has changed significantly, with figures like Rep. James Comer, Chair of the House Oversight Committee, demanding accountability from Minnesota’s Democratic leadership. He questions the apparent failure of state agencies to halt the ongoing fraud, as well as the deletion of critical data from the state’s Department of Human Services records.
This investigation exhibits alarming statistics: up to 90% of those charged in the welfare fraud cases are identified as Somali. Investigators allege that shell companies and nonprofits recklessly filed claims for meals that were never served, relying on fictitious children and imaginary addresses. FBI Director Kash Patel cautioned, “This is the tip of a very large iceberg.”
Public frustration surrounding this situation is palpable. Reports indicate that the funds misappropriated by these schemes surpass the entire annual budget for Minnesota’s corrections system. The New York Times notes, “That is more than Minnesota spends annually to run its Department of Corrections.”
Peter Schweizer, President of the Government Accountability Institute, has described the evidence as “overwhelming,” indicating a pattern of corruption involving Somali nationals. He condemned the manipulation of funds meant to support families, asserting that instead of nurturing American children, these resources were diverted for criminal pursuits.
Legal experts warn that denaturalization remains a daunting process in U.S. law. Supreme Court rulings necessitate that any revocation of citizenship must be based on clear evidence linking illegal or dishonest conduct to the original naturalization. Still, the DHS’s current audit signals a shift toward rigorous examination of various citizenship cases, including green card applications and marital histories.
This heightened level of scrutiny may incite calls for legislative reforms aimed at easing the process of revoking citizenship in cases of fraudulent activity or disloyalty. Emmer’s remarks reflect a growing impatience with those who exploit social benefits without contributing to or assimilating into American culture: “Our nation will not tolerate those who take advantage of our charity…”
While the DHS has not disclosed the exact number of individuals under review, anonymous sources suggest that hundreds of cases are in the audit’s initial phase. Minnesota remains a focal point due to its unique demographics and a documented history of abuse within pandemic-related programs.
As the DHS walks the tightrope of maintaining the integrity of U.S. citizenship, this audit sets the stage for a national conversation about immigration, loyalty, and federal responsibility. With each passing day—and with elections on the horizon—this debate is likely to grow more intense.
"*" indicates required fields
