Beth Macy is emerging as a significant figure in Virginia’s 6th Congressional District race, appealing to voters in a way that draws sharp contrasts with Vice President J.D. Vance. Macy’s background as a seasoned journalist and author gives her a unique lens on the issues that resonate deeply with many in her community. Having spent 25 years at the Roanoke Times and published five nonfiction books, she has articulated the struggles of her hometown, Urbana, Ohio, in a manner that critiques the systems contributing to its decline.
Macy’s memoir, “Paper Girl: A Memoir of Home and Family in a Fractured America,” was released in October and reflects on the challenges she faced while underscoring her commitment to her roots. This personal narrative aligns with themes explored in Vance’s “Hillbilly Elegy,” which also delves into social issues facing Ohio, but the two offer contrasting perspectives. Critics, including Silas House, an esteemed Appalachian writer, suggest that Macy embodies a more authentic representation of her community. “She’s the opposite of J.D. Vance,” House remarked, highlighting a perceived disconnection in Vance’s approach to the working class.
Macy has not shied away from voicing her critiques of Vance’s views. In a September 2024 opinion piece for The New York Times, she expressed anger at Vance’s characterization of Appalachians’ challenges as linked to a “crisis of masculinity.” Instead, Macy attributes the region’s struggles to a history of exploitation by external companies and a political system that has failed its residents. Her work is marked by a clear desire to represent those who feel overlooked and neglected, a sentiment echoed by fellow journalist Lon Wagner, who noted her ability to deeply listen to others.
The support from her friends and colleagues comes not just from admiration but from a shared belief that Macy’s candidacy is rooted in the real-life experiences of the constituents she wishes to serve. As Andrea Pitzer, a close friend and fellow journalist, stated, “People are angry, and people are aching to have somebody who’s willing to listen to them.” This grassroots connection may serve her well as she seeks to address a significant challenge: winning over a district that has not elected a Democrat since 1990.
Macy has articulated a focused vision for her campaign: to make life more affordable for working families, expand healthcare access, and invest in rural communities. Her priorities resonate with those seeking practical solutions over political rhetoric. She suggests that Vance, through his public commentary, often misses the mark by failing to engage meaningfully with the people he describes.
In a comparison of their political arcs, Macy’s evolution from journalist to congressional candidate appears rooted not in personal ambition but in a commitment to social justice and community. “I wasn’t trying to launch a career,” she explained. “I was just, like, doing my job.” It’s a proclamation that underscores her desire to remain connected to the realities of her constituents—illustrating that she sees her engagement not as a stepping stone, but as a responsibility.
As Macy navigates a campaign supported by notable endorsements, such as from Democratic Senator Tim Kaine, the pressure intensifies in a district with a long-standing Republican trend. Nevertheless, her appeal lies not only in her policy proposals, but in her genuine connection to the people she aims to represent. With a commitment to engage with grassroots voices and a critique of complacent political narratives, Macy presents herself as a different kind of leader—one rooted in listening, understanding, and action.
"*" indicates required fields
